French Pedi. Yay or Nay?

It seems like there's a huge split between French pedi lovers and haters. It seems like there's no in between.

In my opinion, it depends:

On freakishly long toe nails : Nay
Exagerated contrast: Nay
On finger-like toes: Nay
Chipped: Nay

Otherwise, I think it can look pretty (see pic)
What's your take on this controversial beauty trend?
***********
Les gusta este tipo de pinta unas en los pies?
Al parecer a la gente o le gusta o lo detesta. A mi me parece bonito si se aplican colores sutiles (no super blancos o irridicentes) Tambien si los dedos de los pies no son super largos (Tu sabes, aquellos que parecen casi tentaculos de lo largos) Y se tienen que mantener brillantes y procuren que no se escarchen!
Te parece bonito el de la foto de arriba?

In Watermelon Sugar!

Image via Wikipedia

After what seems of decades of snobbery against any form of artistic expression in the nail polish department: Nail Art is baaaack! (at least for the Summer season)

The latest craze is the "watermelon pedicure" I think it's total cuteness. But beware, bringing so much attention to you toes DEMANDS that you take extra measures to make sure your feet can handle all the attention they are bound to get.
In the latest issue of Allure , Fergie daunts Nail Art stickers on her tips, admitting that keeping up her manis are a very important part of her routine.

What do you think of this colorful trend? Yay or Nay?